HaRav Nebenzahl asks that his Divrei Torah are not read during Tefillah or the Rabbi's sermon

SIMCHAT YOM TOV VIA LEARNING TORAH
THE BETROTHAL OF HASHEM AND THE JEWISH PEOPLE
We find ourselves in the period of time which can be described as the bonding between Hashem and Knesset Yisrael. Discussions of the shidduch begin during Elul, which as we know the name Elul is comprised of the first letter of each of the words: "ani leDodi veDodi li" "I am for my Beloved and my Beloved is for me". Rosh Hashana is the tenaim, the engagement - when the shidduch is signed and sealed. We find in the Chassidic writings that the seven days in between and not including Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur can be compared to the shiva nekiim - the seven clean days of purification the bride (the Jewish nation) must undergo in preparation for her upcoming wedding on Yom Kippur.
Yom Kippur is the day in which the great union takes place and all obstacles and separations between the loved ones are removed. Following the wedding are seven days of celebration in the chuppah of the Sukkah. The seventy nations - Hashem's creations, are invited and it is in their honor that we offer seventy bulls on Sukkot. At the conclusion of the seven days, the guests take leave and on Shmini Atzeret the Chatan and Kallah enter their permanent home together (this is symbolized by only one bull being brought on Shmini Atzeret). The chut hameshulash "the three ply cord" (Kohelet 4:12) that ties it all together is Simchat Torah: "The Holy One Blessed is
He, the Torah, and the people of Israel are one".
SIMCHA THRUOGH AVODAT HASHEM
Let us see how Chazal describe the joy of the upcoming Yom Tov of Sukkot. We find in a Baraita: "kshehayinu smechim beSimchat Beit Hashoeva, lo rainu sheina be-einenu" "when we rejoiced at the Simchat Beit Hashoeva we did not see any sleep in our eyes" (Sukka 53a). The entire seven days of Sukkot, with the exception of Shabbat, perhaps even Yom Tov, they did not sleep. The Gemara asks how this was possible, is it not well-known that a person cannot go even for three days without sleep? The Gemara answers that they dozed a bit, the rest of the time they were involved in rejoicing of the "Simchat Beit Hashoeva", they learned a bit, ate a bit. The Gemara makes a calculation. They davened, learned, brought sacrifices, and rejoiced in the Simchat Beit Hashoeva - there was no free time.
Today there is no Beit Hamikdash, if we merit speedily in our day, there will be one. We must learn from this, however, that the festivals were not given for us to only spend time in leisurely pursuits, but rather to involve ourselves in service of Hashem. Chazal teach us that Yom Tov (the Rambam in Hilchot Yom Tov adds that this applies to Chol HaMoed as well) should be "chetzyo laHashem vechetzyo lachem" "half of it for Hashem and half of it for yourselves" (Beitza 15b). We must set aside half of the day (according to the Rambam it must be precisely half, but for us an approximation is certainly sufficient) for Torah and prayer, and the other half for eating, drinking, and rejoicing.
SIMCHA THROUGH LEARNING TORAH
My Rebbe HaRav Zolty z"l pointed out that half of the day for Hashem does not imply that we should not feel simcha while learning. Torah study is an integral part of the joy of the festival. Given that our tefilla does not take up half the day there are still several hours left for learning Torah, enabling us to fulfill "Hashem's half of it" in the proper manner. This is the way the Torah wants us to celebrate the festival - half of it rejoicing in physical activities, and half of the joy in spiritual matters - Torah and tefilla. Fulfillment of the mitzvah of simchat Yom Tov implies that half of the joy of the Yom Tov is through learning and prayer, and half is through meat, wine, and other physical pleasures. Eating is rejoicing of the body, the learning is rejoicing of the soul.
LEARNING TORAH IS THE CHETZYO LACHEM
The "Divrei Chaim" from Sanz went even further. He spent the entire night of Shavuot learning, as is customary. He then davened, listened to the Torah reading and then declared "this part was for my own enjoyment - now is the time to fulfill the half for Hashem!" This is a tremendous level. We must view both halves of the day as for us, the learning must bring us joy, in addition to the meat and wine. Not only must we feel a sense of joy from the chetzyo laHashem, but the chetzyo lachem must also be channeled towards serving Hashem and we should not frivolously waste our time during the festivals.
The custom here in Eretz Yisrael and in several communities in chutz la'aretz is not to lay tefillin on Chol Hamoed, this means that the entire eight days of Sukkot (including Shmini Atzeret) we do not wear tefillin. The reason we do not wear tefillin on Shabbat and festivals is that tefillin are referred to as a sign as is Shabbat. If the Shabbat is the sign of Hashem's Providence we do not require any additional sign on our arm and on our head. The Torah writes that the purpose of the sign of the tefillin is "lemaan tihye Torah Hashem beficha" "in order that the Torah of Hashem remains in your mouth". If the Shabbat or Yom Tov (and Chol HaMoed) replace it as signs then they too must serve as a reminder of Hashem's Torah. This means that there is a great obligation to learn Torah on Shabbat and Yom Tov.
BEIN HAZMANIM IS NOT A BREAK FROM AVODAT HASHEM
I would like to add that our obligation to learn and rejoice in Torah applies to the entire upcoming bein hazmanim break as well. The Torah must remain in our mouths then as well. We must take a break and rest, but only the amount of rest that is necessary. The obligation of Torah study applies equally during bein hazmanim as it does the rest of the year. I have never heard of anyone who became ill from having looked in a sefer for a few minutes during bein hazmanim, or even having learned with a chavruta part of the time!
It is true that there are many preparations required for the Yom Tov of Sukkot. You will be busy purchasing your arba minim, many of you will be involved in building sukkahs as well. Those of you who will be with your parents have an opportunity and an obligation to help them as much as you are able to. The entire year we fulfill the mitzvah of honoring our parents by ensuring that they have sons who become talmidei Chachamim. During the bein hazmanim period we have the opportunity to fulfill this in a physical sense as well.
HONORING OUR PARENTS IS A KIDDUSH HASHEM
Helping our parents is also an opportunity for sanctifying Hashem's Name. When people see that one who studies in Yeshiva also helps his parents, this brings about a tremendous Kiddush Hashem. Involvement in chesed and being well-mannered and helping others also creates a Kiddush Hashem. People who witness the pleasant manner of a Yeshiva bachur will aspire to learn themselves and send their sons to Yeshiva to learn, as Chazal teach us:
"'and you shall love Hashem your G-d' (Devarim 6:5), that the name of Heaven be beloved because of you. If someone studies Torah and Mishna and attends to the disciples of the wise, is honest in business, and speaks pleasantly to persons, what do people then say concerning him? Happy the father who taught him Torah, happy the teacher who taught him Torah; woe unto people who have not studied the Torah; for this man has studied the Torah look how fine his ways are, how righteous are his deeds" (Yoma 86a), of him the pasuk states "You are my servant, Israel in whom I take glory" (Yeshayahu 49:3).
A Yeshiva student who does not act properly can, G-d forbid, cause a chillul Hashem.
LEARNING TORAH DURING BEIN HAZMANIM IS A KIDDUSH HASHEM
Learning during bein hazmanim also constitutes a Kiddush Hashem. The Kiddush Hashem would be that people would see that learning Torah is such an integral part of a Yeshiva bachur's being that he is not motivated solely by fear of the Rosh Yeshiva. In fact, learning Torah is a Kiddush Hashem even if there would be no one there to witness it. The Rambam teaches us that one can perform a Kiddush Hashem even in a closed room. When we open a page of Gemara simply because Hashem commanded us to, or for that matter perform any mitzvah with the goal of serving our Creator, this is a Kiddush Hashem, for we have demonstrated that the Word of Hashem is sanctified and important to us. The opposite, G-d forbid, can cause a chillul Hashem.
If, without valid reason, a person neglects his Torah study, his observance of mitzvoth, and does not recite Kriat Shma within the required period of time, this is a chillul Hashem. This desecrates Hashem's Name even if the next morning's newspaper does not contain a banner headling: "X was late for Shul!" When a person demonstrates that mitzvoth are not a high priority, he has desecrated Hashem's Name, how much more worse would this be if his acts indeed became publicized.
The Chazon Ish was once asked if a person is required to learn the same amount during bein hazmanim as he is during the rest of the year. Answered the Chazon Ish: "no not at all ... twelve hours a day will suffice!" Although this might constitute the bein hazmanim of the Chazon Ish, for us perhaps less will suffice, as our Sages teach: "tafasta merube lo tafasta" "if you to grab too much you might be left with nothing"(Sukkah 5a).
TRY SOME TANACH AND MISHNAYOT
Bein Hazmanim may be a good opportunity to learn things that our time in Yeshiva does not afford us the time for. During the regular Yeshiva zman we concentrate on learning Gemara with commentaries. Very little Tanach is studied in the Yeshiva, even so, Hashem did not give us these twenty-four books in order that they remain on the shelf, but in order that we learn and master them. There are many books of Tanach that many of us can claim complete ignorance. It is said of the Vilna Gaon that he would not accept any student to his Yeshiva unless he knew the Tanach more or less by heart. If we were to institute such an entrance requirement at Yeshivat Netiv Aryeh, I am afraid we would not have too many students! (I am not sure, perhaps Rav Bina would be able to find boys in America who fit that requirement.) We need to learn Tanach, but not at the expense of the Sedarim, for the Sedarim must be devoted to studying the Massechet the Yeshiva is currently learning. By the same token, we must also find time to learn Tanach. The same applies to the Mishnayot, if nothing more we must at least be familiar with the Oral Torah, to know the subject of each Massechet what is discussed in Massechet Machshirin and what the subject matter of Massechet Parah is - does it speak about cows or about something else. The Torah is incredibly vast. Would it not be wonderful if we could master a few sedarim of Mishnayot during bein hazmanim! If this is too much to ask, at least some time should be spent learning the Mishnayot.
Rejoicing via eating and drinking is not the true joy, it rather removes what may interfere with our true sense of joy. In our Yom Tov davening we do not recite that the people of Israel should rejoice through meat and wine, rather "veyismechu becha Yisrael mekadshei Shmecha" "may Israel the sanctifiers of Your holiness rejoice in You". We eat in order that our bodily needs not interfere with our ability to rejoice in Hashem. The chetzyo laHashem "half of it for Hashem", the learning of Torah on Yom Tov, brings true joy to the soul and is thus a fulfillment of the mitzvah of simchat Yom Tov.
MAINTAINING THE GAINS OF YOM KIPPUR
We are still on a spiritual high from the uplifting Yom Kippur davening here in Yeshiva. May this feeling remain with us and may it be the will of Hashem that we merit acting in a way commensurate with the tremendous awakening we are experiencing at this moment. May it be the will of Hashem that we soon be able to fulfill the mitzvah of aliyah leregel to the Beit HaMikdash and offer the seventy bulls, the other communal korbanot of Sukkot as well as our own shalmei simcha, shalmei chagiga, and olat reiyah. Amen.
|